強奸 VS 傷人



  • 剛和朋友作激烈辯論,請各位比D意見。

    如果你係法官,一個人強奸 VS 一個人持刀傷人(吉人一刀),你會點判?

    Maxmium Penalty 10 Years.



    Example 1:10, 10:1 or 8:10, 10:8





  • 10:10



  • 全部高院, 量刑起點7yrs...



  • 傷人都要睇麻咩情況...


    強姦就唔駛諗一定重判~



  • 10:10



  • 我覺得1:10, 我朋友覺得5:10。


    我覺得強奸唔洗死, 吉一刀會死。強奸有愛的成份, 吉一刀只有恨。


    我朋友覺得吉一刀會康復,但強奸會一生心靈受創。



  • 持刀傷人(吉人一刀)分分鐘告佢1級謀殺... 判老終...



  • depend on how old is the gal that she rape also depends on how old and how much he rob




  • 強奸有愛的成份??





    咩道理...





    咁如果同一男女朋友分手...因愛成恨..又涉唔涉及愛呢?








    心靈傷害比肉體大~




  • 我覺得強奸唔洗死, 吉一刀會死。強奸有愛的成份, 吉一刀只有恨。





    ---------------------------------------------





    第1次聽, 強姦有愛的成份...哈哈, 咁都得?




  • 文度王: 傷人都要睇麻咩情況... 強姦就唔駛諗一定重判~





    我的觀點剛剛相反,強姦要睇麻咩情況,傷人就一定重判(分分鐘會死人)。




  • 強奸入咗去就生不如死...



  • 殺人有愛的成份, 係咪判輕 D??





    short short 地



  • 多餘...咩 CASE 都要睇咩情況啦



  • 強姦案陪審團通常會憐憫苦主... 好多都橫抹...



  • yes, 痴線無論犯咩事都唔洗判咁重



  • ah_jer





    若你有日有條麻甩佬插你 c 眼,都係有愛的成份,你吾好嬲佢呀~



  • b女 replied @ 2008-04-17 1:36 pm





    ah_jer





    若你有日有條麻甩佬插你 c 眼,都係有愛的成份,你吾好嬲佢呀~





    >>>>>>>>>>>>>> xDDDDDDDDDDDDD



  • 咁傷人既目標都有分~





    好似係兩個唔識既人係街嘈...一時意氣用事去吉左對方一野


    同一早同個人有仇...去吉佢一野有唔同嘛





    強姦都係一樣...不過我始終覺得可能對方唔會死...但係一世既心靈傷害比死更難受~



  • 若你有日有條麻甩佬插你 c 眼,都係有愛的成份,你吾好嬲佢呀~





    by b女 - 04/17/08 13:36





    最多講stop....condom pls...if u love me~



  • 強奸有愛的成份?? <<<<< first time to hear.......so sock



  • B女, Yes, 我寧願佢吉我一野都唔想佢捅我一刀。



  • 文度王: 一世既心靈傷害比死更難受.





    Yes, I think that's the key point of my argument. Nothing is worst than losing the life.



  • 失覺哂, 原來你有某種傾向



  • B女, Yes, 我寧願佢吉我一野都唔想佢捅我一刀。





    by ah_jer - 04/17/08 13:40





    即係如果有條友吉完你之後同你d朋友講..


    話本來諗住係捅你...點知你叫佢唔好...求佢吉你就算...你覺得以為做人會舒服d?



  • ah_jer replied @ 2008-04-17 1:44 pm





    文度王: 一世既心靈傷害比死更難受.





    Yes, I think that's the key point of my argument. Nothing is worst than losing the life.





    ===============================





    喂, 你睇唔睇得明人地講咩架



  • 文度王: 一世既心靈傷害比死更難受.





    Yes, I think that's the key point of my argument. Nothing is worst than losing the life.





    by ah_jer - 04/17/08 13:44





    如果你咁講就唔係傷人....係老謀啦~



  • Please don't misunderstand me.


    強奸有愛的成份是相對持刀傷人。Doesn't mean 因愛而強奸.





    Sorry for my misleading.



  • ah_jer





    桶一刀= 死, 咁吾該你改左你個 topic 先啦,





    9吾搭8, 梗係無野緊要得過命仔~



  • 會死就唔止10yrs la...



  • 持刀傷人差不多=老謀(我覺得)



  • Please don't misunderstand me.


    強奸有愛的成份是相對持刀傷人。Doesn't mean 因愛而強奸.





    Sorry for my misleading.





    by ah_jer - 04/17/08 13:47





    你咁講完我都係唔明....


    你知唔知咩叫愛~



  • 強奸有愛的成份是相對持刀傷人>>>>>> 真係唔明你 d logic, 強姦會有愛的成份??????? 咩人呢架, 講咩呀



  • 文度王


    今日d post 同你差唔多時間出, 又差唔多意思嘅, 哈哈



  • 持刀傷人差不多=老謀(我覺得)





    by ah_jer - 04/17/08 13:51





    死左先算謀殺.....你知唔知架~


    即係你吉人一野....佢死左唔一定老謀..可能係誤殺





    謀殺都分一級二級誤殺....同自衛殺人...



  • 捅我一刀會(可能)死


    但吉我一野一定唔洗死





    所以我覺得持刀傷人大罪好多!







  • 文度王


    今日d post 同你差唔多時間出, 又差唔多意思嘅, 哈哈





    by behind - 04/17/08 13:53





    可能我地既思維比較正常~



  • 文度王 replied @ 2008-04-17 1:57 pm





    文度王


    今日d post 同你差唔多時間出, 又差唔多意思嘅, 哈哈





    by behind - 04/17/08 13:53





    可能我地既思維比較正常~





    =========================





    呢個係相對的, 我一路都唔覺, 係剛剛先有咁嘅感覺





    多謝樓主



  • make it simple, i perfer 死 better than 強姦 by guy....that's what gal think u know



  • make it simple, i perfer 死 better than 強姦 by guy....that's what gal think u know





    by Appleforjuly - 04/17/08 14:01





    假設吳彥祖強姦你呢~



  • ah_jer





    吾怕, 就算吾好彩揾左你做陪審團, 你都係去決定有無罪的一票,





    好彩法官要讀多幾年書先做得啫~





    記住,係強姦。





    強奸, 可能係解扮奸人堅?? 你小學中文老師有無教?



  • 本人身處大陸, 今日看到新聞. 發覺強奸和持刀傷人判刑相約. 才有這debate. 觀點有錯請多多包容. 我會反省



  • Appleforjuly replied @ 2008-04-17 2:01 pm





    make it simple, i perfer 死 better than 強姦 by guy....that's what gal think u know








    你咁貞烈, iou~ ^^



  • 文度王 replied @ 2008-04-17 2:05 pm





    假設吳彥祖強姦你呢~





    文王





    乜吳生條 jj 幼 d?



  • 假設吳彥祖強姦你呢


    then it is not 強, is voluntary la, do u understand what is meaning of 強 ar



  • 文度王 replied @ 2008-04-17 2:05 pm





    假設吳彥祖強姦你呢~





    文王





    乜吳生條 jj 幼 d?





    by b女 - 04/17/08 14:08





    你咁都知....^^



  • 好彩法官要讀多幾年書先做得啫~


    b女 - give me 555555 iou also



  • 觀點有錯請多多包容. 我會反省 >>>> 都是成年人啦, 無話對錯嘅, 只是你的立論基礎怪怪的



  • 假設吳彥祖強姦你呢


    then it is not 強, is voluntary la, do u understand what is meaning of 強 ar





    by Appleforjuly - 04/17/08 14:10





    我都係up下...我知


    可能係你強返佢都唔定...^^


    女人強唔強姦到男人呢......咁個律師可以話你唔想可以唔硬...但係又控制唔到wor~




  • 好彩法官要讀多幾年書先做得啫~


    b女 - give me 555555 iou also





    by Appleforjuly - 04/17/08 14:11





    請問法官要讀幾多年呀.....


login to reply
 

looks like your connection to she.com messageboard was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.